This is an earlier experiment. Read the amendments below before treating its findings as current.
The question
Could changing room size and early-reaction strength together find what one-at-a-time sweeps missed? Could room that shrinks at high speed get the best of both?
What was tested
Three combinations flew the wing's crossing and its storm and standard mixed test sets. The best, three-quarter room with early reaction at strength 5, went through the full adoption checks on all airframes. The shrinking room was judged on paper from existing results.
What was found then
Three-quarter room held both wing test sets and cut wing mixed-set collisions from 544 to 101, the lowest yet. It was the first setting to pass the adoption rule: idealised instant-response craft identical, no test set worse, losses at least halved in all 12 crossing conditions. The wing's fastest case only just made it (ratio 0.49), and losses still rose with speed on three airframes. A quarter room failed the storm test. The shrinking room was set aside: crowded and funnel scenarios need room at every speed.
What we learned later
Two fresh sets of layouts confirmed the wing still halves its losses at 22 m/s (a ratio of 0.36 there).
research/data/oos/tau_j2edge.md
A later full-room candidate recorded a lower wing mixed-set count (75 on the same layouts).
research/data/oos/wing_c5_gate.md
What changed
nothing yet (adopted in the next step)
Numbers and source references
- Three
- combinations tried (3/4 bubble with charge 4 or 5; 1/4 bubble with charge 2)research/data/oos/tau_joint.md
- 308 to 232
- wing storm-set collisions, three-quarter bubble with charge 4 or 5research/data/oos/tau_joint.md
- 544 to 101
- wing matrix collisions, three-quarter bubble with charge 5research/data/oos/tau_joint.md
- 308 to 495
- wing storm-set collisions, quarter bubble with charge 2research/data/oos/tau_joint.md
- 215
- instant-response craft rows identicalresearch/data/oos/tau_adopt_j2_record.md
- 12
- crossing conditions all at half or less of today's lossesresearch/data/oos/tau_j2gate.md (Registered)
- 3 / 10 / 47
- wing lost per run, new setting (3.3 / 10 / 46.7)research/data/oos/tau_j2gate.md
- 10 / 51 / 95
- wing lost per run, today's controllerresearch/data/oos/tau_j2gate.md
- 0 / 0 / 3; 2 / 9 / 17; 2 / 12 / 30
- multirotor / eVTOL / delayed-sideways lost per run under the new setting at 8 / 16 / 22 m/sresearch/data/oos/tau_j2gate.md
- 0.49
- wing 22 m/s loss ratio vs today'sresearch/data/oos/tau_j2gate.md